| Product and process fit | 18% | Supported polymer, POY denier range, filament count, cross-section options, and intended end uses. | Confirm the proposed configuration can produce every required product using documented specifications and representative trial results. | 0–5 |
| Capacity and productivity | 14% | Guaranteed output in kg/h, number of spinning positions, operating shifts, and stated production assumptions. | Compare guaranteed saleable output with the project requirement; check whether the calculation accounts for product mix and planned operating time. | 0–5 |
| Winding performance | 14% | Take-up speed range in m/min, winding positions, package dimensions and mass, traverse details, and doffing method. | Match the proposed operating window and package format to the buyer’s product and downstream handling requirements; confirm by trial and acceptance testing. | 0–5 |
| Yarn quality and consistency | 14% | Trial data for denier variation, package build, yarn breaks, and other quality measures specified for the product. | Compare results across positions and packages against agreed product specifications; request test methods, sample size, and trial conditions. | 0–5 |
| Reliability and availability | 10% | Operating references, maintenance schedule, critical component list, and availability data where available. | Check the measurement period and definition. A common calculation is operating time ÷ planned production time; agree exclusions before comparing offers. | 0–5 |
| Energy and resource consumption | 8% | Power consumption and any relevant compressed-air, cooling-water, or other utility requirements. | Compare kWh/kg and utility use only when the measurement boundary, product, output rate, and operating conditions are equivalent. | 0–5 |
| Automation and controls | 6% | Control and monitoring functions, alarm history, recipe management, data export, and automation options. | Verify functions during a demonstration and confirm compatibility with the plant’s operating procedures and information systems. | 0–5 |
| Installation and site requirements | 5% | Machine layout, foundation and floor-load data, electrical requirements, utilities, and environmental conditions. | Check the supplier’s documented requirements against the project site survey and facility capacity before order placement. | 0–5 |
| Safety and regulatory documentation | 5% | Risk assessment, guarding details, operating and maintenance instructions, and conformity documents applicable to the destination market. | Review documentation against the project location’s applicable regulations and the buyer’s site safety requirements. | 0–5 |
| Service, spares, and commissioning | 6% | Commissioning scope, training plan, spare-parts list and lead times, service coverage, and written response commitments. | Evaluate the contractual service plan, availability of critical spares, and support arrangements for the installation location. | 0–5 |
| Total evaluation weight | 100% | Weighted result = Σ (criterion weight × score ÷ 5). Use the same evidence requirements and scoring rules for every bid. | — |
| Scoring guide: 0 = no evidence; 1 = major gaps; 2 = partially meets requirements; 3 = meets documented requirements; 4 = exceeds requirements with verified evidence; 5 = exceeds requirements and is confirmed by an agreed production trial. Technical targets should be defined for the specific product, site, and contract rather than treated as universal machine standards. |