| Energy Efficiency | 25% | Certified full-load and part-load performance data for the proposed model and project conditions. | Provides ratings applicable to the specified conditions, identifies the rating method, and supplies AHRI-certified performance where the product and rating are within the applicable certification program. Compare IPLV/NPLV only when the rating conditions are relevant to the project. | _____ |
| Application Fit and Operating Range | 15% | Available capacity, entering and leaving water temperatures, ambient limits, flow requirements, and operating envelope. | Submits project-specific selection data and confirms that the proposed unit can meet the design load and stated operating conditions without relying on assumptions that are not documented. | _____ |
| Reliability and Maintainability | 15% | Maintenance schedule, recommended spare parts, service procedures, and relevant operating references. | Provides clear maintenance requirements, parts information, and access requirements. References should be relevant to comparable equipment and operating conditions. | _____ |
| Safety and Regulatory Compliance | 10% | Applicable safety, refrigerant, electrical, and energy-code documentation for the project location. | Documents applicable requirements, including relevant editions of standards such as ASHRAE 15 for refrigeration-system safety and ASHRAE 34 for refrigerant designation and safety classification. Confirm local code requirements with the project team. | _____ |
| Service and Technical Support | 15% | Local service coverage, technician qualifications, response arrangements, commissioning support, and parts availability. | Identifies the responsible service organization, support process, geographic coverage, and availability of trained technicians and replacement parts for the equipment offered. | _____ |
| Controls and System Integration | 8% | Controls sequence, available communication protocols, alarms, trend points, and interface requirements. | Provides a controls submittal that identifies supported interfaces and points, explains required gateways or licenses, and describes how the chiller will integrate with the building management system. | _____ |
| Lifecycle Cost and Warranty | 7% | Warranty terms, exclusions, recommended service costs, energy assumptions, and expected replacement items. | Supplies written warranty terms and a transparent lifecycle-cost estimate with stated assumptions. Compare alternatives using the same load profile, energy rates, and analysis period. | _____ |
| Submittals and Documentation | 5% | Selection report, dimensional drawings, electrical data, installation requirements, operation manuals, and product certifications. | Provides complete, model-specific documentation suitable for design review, installation planning, commissioning, and ongoing operation. | _____ |