| 1 | Product Compliance and Design Range | 20% | Availability of concentric, double-offset, and triple-offset designs; wafer, lug, and flanged configurations; resilient and metal-seated options. | Products should be designed and tested against applicable requirements such as API 609, EN 593, or equivalent national standards. | Current datasheets, dimensional drawings, pressure-temperature charts, and third-party certificates. | 0–10 points multiplied by 20% |
| 2 | Pressure, Temperature, and Size Capability | 15% | Maximum nominal size, pressure class or PN rating, operating temperature range, and suitability for liquid, gas, steam, or abrasive service. | Published limits must be supported by recognized pressure-temperature ratings and applicable testing requirements. | Certified technical specifications, material compatibility charts, and application references. | 0–10 points multiplied by 15% |
| 3 | Sealing and Leakage Performance | 15% | Seat leakage class, shell-test performance, shaft-seal design, fire-safe options, and fugitive-emission capability. | Testing may be evaluated against ISO 5208, EN 12266-1, API 598, API 607, ISO 15848-1, or the specified project standard. | Test reports, fire-safe certificates, fugitive-emission certificates, and inspection records. | 0–10 points multiplied by 15% |
| 4 | Materials and Corrosion Resistance | 10% | Body, disc, stem, seat, and coating materials; resistance to seawater, chemicals, high-purity fluids, and abrasive media. | Material selection should match the fluid, temperature, pressure, corrosion risk, and applicable material standards. | Material test certificates, coating specifications, NACE-related documentation where applicable, and traceability records. | 0–10 points multiplied by 10% |
| 5 | Actuation and Automation Compatibility | 10% | Manual, pneumatic, electric, and hydraulic actuation; mounting interface; torque data; position indication; control accessories. | Valve mounting should be compatible with ISO 5211 interfaces or the project-specific actuator standard. | Actuator sizing calculations, torque curves, mounting drawings, wiring diagrams, and control-valve documentation. | 0–10 points multiplied by 10% |
| 6 | Quality Management and Manufacturing Control | 10% | Quality-management certification, inspection plans, calibration control, nonconformance handling, and production traceability. | An independently verified quality-management system based on ISO 9001 is a baseline requirement for international procurement. | Valid certificates, audit summaries, inspection and test plans, process records, and calibration certificates. | 0–10 points multiplied by 10% |
| 7 | Delivery Capacity and Supply Reliability | 10% | Quoted lead time, production capacity, spare-parts availability, export documentation, and order-status transparency. | Evaluation should use documented performance over recent comparable orders rather than unsupported delivery claims. | Recent delivery records, capacity statements, inventory policies, packing lists, and export references. | 0–10 points multiplied by 10% |
| 8 | After-Sales Service and Technical Support | 5% | Commissioning assistance, troubleshooting response, maintenance guidance, training, warranty terms, and local service coverage. | Support commitments should specify response times, warranty scope, exclusions, and spare-parts responsibilities. | Service-level agreements, warranty documents, manuals, training records, and support contact procedures. | 0–10 points multiplied by 5% |
| 9 | Total Cost of Ownership | 5% | Purchase price, actuator cost, installation requirements, maintenance intervals, spare-parts cost, energy use, and expected service life. | The lowest purchase price should not receive the highest score unless lifecycle costs and performance requirements are also competitive. | Comparable quotations, maintenance schedules, spare-parts lists, energy calculations, and lifecycle-cost models. | 0–10 points multiplied by 5% |